Awards

1958 Hall of Fame Results

By Patrick Mondout

No new members were voted into National Baseball Hall of Fame by the writers for 1958.

Votes by members of the BBWAA were tabulated by the National Baseball Hall of Fame. At least 200 votes were needed to be elected.

VOTING RESULTS... NAME VOTES % CAT. TIMES Max Carey 136 51.1% P 14th Edd Roush 112 42.1% P 18th Red Ruffing 99 37.2% P 11th Hack Wilson 94 35.3% P 14th Kiki Cuyler 90 33.8% P 10th Sam Rice 90 33.8% P 11th Tony Lazzeri 80 30.1% P 13th Luke Appling 77 28.9% P 4th Lefty Gomez 76 28.6% P 13th Burleigh Grimes 71 26.7% P 12th Red Faber 68 25.6% P 14th Lou Boudreau 64 24.1% P 2nd Jim Bottomley 57 21.4% P 10th Joe Medwick 50 18.8% P 3rd Pepper Martin 46 17.3% P 11th Hank Gowdy 45 16.9% P 16th Bucky Harris 45 16.9% M 9th Dave Bancroft 43 16.2% P 14th Lloyd Waner 39 14.7% P 6th Waite Hoyt 37 13.9% P 13th Chuck Klein 36 13.5% P 9th Johnny Vander Meer 35 13.2% P 3rd Earle Combs 34 12.8% P 12th Stan Coveleski 34 12.8% P 5th Al Lopez 34 12.8% M 5th Bucky Walters 33 12.4% P 5th Eppa Rixey 32 12.0% P 14th Leo Durocher 28 10.5% M 5th Lefty O'Doul 27 10.2% P 8th Jimmie Dykes 26 9.8% P 9th Goose Goslin 26 9.8% P 7th Charlie Grimm 26 9.8% P 10th Bobby Doerr 25 9.4% P 3rd Jesse Haines 22 8.3% P 10th Heinie Manush 22 8.3% P 4th Nick Altrock 20 7.5% P 7th Billy Southworth 18 6.8% P 8th Freddie Fitzsimmons 16 6.0% P 5th Paul Derringer 15 5.6% P 6th Dolf Luque 15 5.6% P 8th Earl Averill 14 5.3% P 5th Babe Herman 13 4.9% P 11th Art Nehf 13 4.9% P 11th Red Rolfe 13 4.9% P 6th Chick Hafey 12 4.5% P 10th Terry Moore 12 4.5% P 3rd Schoolboy Rowe 12 4.5% P 1st Tommy Bridges 11 4.1% P 2nd Joe Gordon 11 4.1% P 4th Tommy Henrich 11 4.1% P 4th Travis Jackson 11 4.1% P 10th Steve O'Neill 10 3.8% P 7th Muddy Ruel 10 3.8% P 9th Wes Ferrell 9 3.4% P 4th Joe Judge 9 3.4% P 6th Charlie Keller 9 3.4% P 3rd Jack Quinn 9 3.4% P 3rd Wally Schang 8 3.0% P 4th Birdie Tebbetts 8 3.0% P 1st Glenn Wright 8 3.0% P 10th Howard Ehmke 7 2.6% P 9th Billy Herman 7 2.6% P 3rd Eddie Rommel 7 2.6% P 7th Stan Hack 6 2.3% P 6th Mel Harder 6 2.3% P 6th Pinky Higgins 6 2.3% P 3rd Carl Mays 6 2.3% P 1st Pete Reiser 6 2.3% P 1st Charley Root 6 2.3% P 5th Arky Vaughan 6 2.3% P 5th Cy Williams 6 2.3% P 12th Joe Bush 5 1.9% P 1st Frankie Crosetti 5 1.9% P 4th Joe Dugan 5 1.9% P 6th Orval Grove 5 1.9% P 1st Fielder Jones 5 1.9% P 4th Freddie Lindstrom 5 1.9% P 3rd Firpo Marberry 5 1.9% P 3rd Bob Meusel 5 1.9% P 10th Moe Berg 4 1.5% P 1st Max Bishop 4 1.5% P 3rd Dolph Camilli 4 1.5% P 3rd Cookie Lavagetto 4 1.5% P 1st Ernie Lombardi 4 1.5% P 4th Urban Shocker 4 1.5% P 5th George Uhle 4 1.5% P 2nd Charlie Berry 3 1.1% P 2nd Mort Cooper 3 1.1% P 2nd Tony Cuccinello 3 1.1% P 2nd Bill Doak 3 1.1% P 1st Lew Fonseca 3 1.1% P 4th Mike Gonzalez 3 1.1% P 4th Frankie Gustine 3 1.1% P 1st Willie Kamm 3 1.1% P 1st Bob O'Farrell 3 1.1% P 2nd Luke Sewell 3 1.1% P 2nd Billy Werber 3 1.1% P 4th Jimmie Wilson 3 1.1% P 10th Wally Berger 2 0.8% P 2nd Ossie Bluege 2 0.8% P 5th Doc Cramer 2 0.8% P 2nd Tommy Holmes 2 0.8% P 1st George Kelly 2 0.8% P 5th Ray Kremer 2 0.8% P 2nd Freddy Leach 2 0.8% P 1st Joe McCarthy 2 0.8% M 5th Marty McManus 2 0.8% P 1st Lee Meadows 2 0.8% P 1st Van Mungo 2 0.8% P 3rd Cy Perkins 2 0.8% P 1st Bill Sherdel 2 0.8% P 8th Lon Warneke 2 0.8% P 2nd Earl Whitehill 2 0.8% P 2nd Sparky Adams 1 0.4% P 1st Jimmy Austin 1 0.4% P 1st Dick Bartell 1 0.4% P 3rd Larry Benton 1 0.4% P 1st Ray Blades 1 0.4% P 1st George Case 1 0.4% P